Andrew Hawkins out of bounds TD catch

[Storm]

I was at the game and from where I was sitting it looked like he got both feet down for a TD, for some reason they didn't show the replay on the big screen and the play wasn't challenged, Was wondering if he was out of bounds.


Why don't they show replays on the big screen? seems like it could be a good tool for the coaching staff to determine whether to challenge a play or not

[henrizzle]

I just rewatched the game and his left or right foot was out of bounds before he dragged the other one in

[Ryan Mc]

He was out, sadly. He did a great job dragging the back foot, but first foot came down on the line.

[Dmac18]

He was out, trust me if he was in then they would have replayed it.

[McC]

Originally Posted by Storm

I was at the game and from where I was sitting it looked like he got both feet down for a TD, for some reason they didn't show the replay on the big screen and the play wasn't challenged, Was wondering if he was out of bounds.


Why don't they show replays on the big screen? seems like it could be a good tool for the coaching staff to determine whether to challenge a play or not

The first foot that landed--the left, I believe, came down out of bounds.

[Storm]

Thanks guys, now I know lol

[corpjet]

Def out of bounds, would have loved for him to get his second TD of the game

the sad part was he was wide open, Andy just led him a bit too far

as a side note how about the throw and catch for his first TD of the game!

[Storm]

Originally Posted by Dmac18

He was out, trust me if he was in then they would have replayed it.

Why wouldn't they replay it so the coaches can get a heads up on whether to challenge the play or not?

[henrizzle]

Originally Posted by Storm

Why wouldn't they replay it so the coaches can get a heads up on whether to challenge the play or not?

The coaches don't really look to the big screen to look if they should challenge. They have a guy up in the booth that tells them whether to challenge or not.

Still doesn't explain why they didn't replay it though

[Sallad82]

Originally Posted by corpjet

Def out of bounds, would have loved for him to get his second TD of the game

the sad part was he was wide open, Andy just led him a bit too far

as a side note how about the throw and catch for his first TD of the game!

Good throw, Hawkins doesnt have the long reach like most WRs. Aj makes the TD.

[Storm]

Originally Posted by henrizzle

The coaches don't really look to the big screen to look if they should challenge. They have a guy up in the booth that tells them whether to challenge or not.

Still doesn't explain why they didn't replay it though

I see coaches and players in other games look up to the big screen after a play all the time, also I'm not so sure the Bengals have a guy in the booth whos job it is to look at replays

[whodey1302]

Originally Posted by corpjet

Def out of bounds, would have loved for him to get his second TD of the game

the sad part was he was wide open, Andy just led him a bit too far

as a side note how about the throw and catch for his first TD of the game!

It was a good throw by Andy considering he was on the run when he threw it. Bad footwork by Hawk if you ask me. His left foot appeared to be out of bounds before he caught the ball. And it wasn't like he was fully extended either.