If you could have one player.......

[ibengals]

Originally Posted by Shake n Blake

I watched 4 games with Andrew Luck last year. He was good at hitting wide open receivers, but I don't think I ever saw him throw through a tight window with any accuracy. The Lions game I saw was a complete joke. The Lions gave the game away.

Then you're being ignorant. First clip I found:

http://www.nfl.com/videos/nfl-game-h...uck-highlights

Makes half a dozen throws into tight windows. Obviously flukes though.

[Shake n Blake]

Originally Posted by ibengals

Then you're being ignorant. First clip I found:

http://www.nfl.com/videos/nfl-game-h...uck-highlights

Makes half a dozen throws into tight windows. Obviously flukes though.

The "highlights" of that clip:

- a TE screen
- Luck picking on Ray Lewis, who looked pitiful in coverage (like worse than Rey)
- The announcer saying "great catch" and "he was wide open" on 2 separate plays
- Luck throwing a bad INT
- Luck leading an offense that scored 9 points in the playoffs
-Luck finished 28 of 54 (51.9%) for 288 yards, zero TDs and the pick. Passer rating was 59.8.

Of the 9 plays on that clip, there was:

1 run
A grand total of 2 throws to the outside, 1 the announcer dubbed a "beautiful catch" and 1 INT
4 throws to the middle, where Rey looked awful (on the 3rd and 26 completion, Ravens were in a prevent)
1 TE screen
1 throw to deep middle, the WR was "wide open".

So what did you see that was so impressive?

[BANJAXED]

I wouldn't mind some Julio Jones.

[ibengals]

Originally Posted by Shake n Blake

The "highlights" of that clip:

- a TE screen
- Luck picking on Ray Lewis, who looked pitiful in coverage (like worse than Rey)
- The announcer saying "great catch" and "he was wide open" on 2 separate plays
- Luck throwing a bad INT
- Luck leading an offense that scored 9 points in the playoffs
-Luck finished 28 of 54 (51.9%) for 288 yards, zero TDs and the pick. Passer rating was 59.8.

Of the 9 plays on that clip, there was:

1 run
A grand total of 2 throws to the outside, 1 the announcer dubbed a "beautiful catch" and 1 INT
4 throws to the middle, where Rey looked awful (on the 3rd and 26 completion, Ravens were in a prevent)
1 TE screen
1 throw to deep middle, the WR was "wide open".

So what did you see that was so impressive?

I'm done arguing. You're going to see whatever you want to see, so I'm just wasting my time.

Agree to disagree.

[BANJAXED]

Originally Posted by ibengals

I'm done arguing. You're going to see whatever you want to see, so I'm just wasting my time.

Agree to disagree.

Whimps give up!

[ibengals]

Originally Posted by BANJAXED

Whimps give up!