Boling or Robinson?

[Natikid873]

Personally, I think if either were replaced, it'd be Boling, but I think both players have earned their starting positions.

[pulses]

depends on who we draft to be honest.

[Natikid873]

The question was supposed to be: who would YOU rather replace?

[momadance02]

Neither

[pulses]

Originally Posted by Natikid873

The question was supposed to be: who would YOU rather replace?

both

[mulligan]

Dennis Roland, Manny Lawson, Brandon Tate, Bernard Scott, Richard Quinn, Chris Crocker, Nate Clements, Brian Leonard, Jeromi Miles, & Robert Sands.

After we replace these guys, then perhaps there will be room for discussion about players that could be upgraded.

[Lolli]

Originally Posted by Natikid873

Personally, I think if either were replaced, it'd be Boling, but I think both players have earned their starting positions.

You keep them both. If by some miracle Warmack falls to you, you see who is better at Center, Boling or Robinson with the other guy being the 1st reserve.

If Cooper falls to you, same thing, but you might try him at Center as well. Having 2 athletic pullers on the field in Cooper and Boling would be interesting.

Jones or Frederick would displace Robinson.

[mulligan]

Originally Posted by Lolli

You keep them both. If by some miracle Warmack falls to you, you see who is better at Center, Boling or Robinson with the other guy being the 1st reserve.

If Cooper falls to you, same thing, but you might try him at Center as well. Having 2 athletic pullers on the field in Cooper and Boling would be interesting.

Jones or Frederick would displace Robinson.

Jones or Frederick would displace Cook, and Robinson would be the C2. Right?

[Lolli]

Originally Posted by mulligan

Jones or Frederick would displace Cook, and Robinson would be the C2. Right?

Affirmative, I meant as the starter. I pray Cook is gone.

They keep 5 interior guys on the roster.

Zeitler
Boling
Robinson
Draft Pick
Vet

[mulligan]

Originally Posted by Lolli

Affirmative, I meant as the starter. I pray Cook is gone.

They keep 5 interior guys on the roster.

Zeitler
Boling
Robinson
Draft Pick
Vet

As I foresee it,

LT: Whit/Collins
LG: Boling/Wharton
C: Rookie/Robinson
RG: Zeitler
RT: Smith/Rookie

[pulses]

Originally Posted by mulligan

As I foresee it,

LT: Whit/Collins
LG: Boling/Wharton
C: Rookie/Robinson
RG: Zeitler
RT: Smith/Rookie

would you mind if they drafted Justin Pugh OT with 2b?

[OchoCincos]

Originally Posted by pulses

would you mind if they drafted Justin Pugh OT with 2b?

You got a huge man crush on Pugh heh. Although his last name is fun to try and say.

[mulligan]

Originally Posted by pulses

would you mind if they drafted Justin Pugh OT with 2b?

I believe that we disagree on this.

I feel that the Bengals NEED to get impact players at LB (or 2), RB (or 2), Safety (or 2) in this off-season.

To me, this is the clear priority.

After these positions are satisfied, I would consider upgrading Dennis Roland. The earliest I would prefer a RT2 would be in the 5th (comp pick, if applicable) or the 6th.

[phil413]

Draft Barret Jones and let them fight over it.

[Bech72]

Going with neither. Boling is a starter and will remain that; Robinson is a valuable backup and not worth replacing at this point.

[Bech72]

Originally Posted by mulligan

I believe that we disagree on this.

I feel that the Bengals NEED to get impact players at LB (or 2), RB (or 2), Safety (or 2) in this off-season.

To me, this is the clear priority.

After these positions are satisfied, I would consider upgrading Dennis Roland. The earliest I would prefer a RT2 would be in the 5th (comp pick, if applicable) or the 6th.

Completely agree on RT; even if we lose Smith, I believe Collins could start and perform well.

[TGISunday]

Originally Posted by mulligan

Dennis Roland, Manny Lawson, Brandon Tate, Bernard Scott, Richard Quinn, Chris Crocker, Nate Clements, Brian Leonard, Jeromi Miles, & Robert Sands.

After we replace these guys, then perhaps there will be room for discussion about players that could be upgraded.

This.

[tailgaterbob]

I believe we keep both.I think we should draft Frederick to play at RT guard and move Zeitler to LT guard.Boling will become back-up guard and center.Frederick will be back-up center behind Cook.We should draft Wagner to replace Roland at back-up tackle and a real tackle eligible cause he has played tight end and might be able to catch a pass.He could also start grooming to replace Whitworth in the future.We will have Whitworth-Zeitler-Cook-Frederick-Smith and have Collins-Boling-Robinson-Wagner backing up.

[Natikid873]

Originally Posted by tailgaterbob

I believe we keep both.I think we should draft Frederick to play at RT guard and move Zeitler to LT guard.Boling will become back-up guard and center.Frederick will be back-up center behind Cook.We should draft Wagner to replace Roland at back-up tackle and a real tackle eligible cause he has played tight end and might be able to catch a pass.He could also start grooming to replace Whitworth in the future.We will have Whitworth-Zeitler-Cook-Frederick-Smith and have Collins-Boling-Robinson-Wagner backing up.

Why not have Frederick at LG and keep Zietler and RG? And Cook over Robinson?!

[Bengal4ever68]

Wharton starts over Boling. We draft Center Barrett Jones and keep both Boling & Robinson as backups.

[tailgaterbob]

Originally Posted by Natikid873

Why not have Frederick at LG and keep Zietler and RG? And Cook over Robinson?!

Frederick has the build of a RG more than Zeitler who has a LG build and ability to pull.He also was a pulling LG in college.Think of Frederick as a young Bobbie Williams.He can also serve as 3rd center incase we need to add another player at another position on game day and go light one man on the line.Cook is our starter and was not at 100% when he came back but with the off season to get back to full go he will remain and Robinson will be his back up and gain additional knowledge to replace him in the future.

[OSUfan]

Originally Posted by Natikid873

The question was supposed to be: who would YOU rather replace?

Neither.

[Luvnit2]

Originally Posted by Natikid873

Personally, I think if either were replaced, it'd be Boling, but I think both players have earned their starting positions.

I see Cook starting at center if he is healthy and Wharton starting at LG if he is healthy.