Would Julius Peppers for "Ocho Cinco" and Our 3rd round pick be a fair deal?

[pigskincrazy]

Peppers seems intent upon leaving the Panthers, and could be the bona fide pass rushing specialist that the Bengals are desperate to add to our defense. Chad may be indispensable to our offense, at this time, with the departure of TJ? I don't know if the Bengals will land a 3rd or 4th round comp pick in this year's Draft to partially offset the team's having to give up a draft pick, along with #85, to get this deal done.

Is Peppers too old at age 29 to be a good pick up for the Bengals, who can play both DE and OLB? Can the Bengals find a viable substitute for #85 on our current roster to replace him with as a deep threat like Henry, perhaps, or are we too thin at the WR position?

Will Delhomme be able to get the ball to Chad, and would Johnson be a good complement to Steve Smith for the Carolina Panthers?

So would this be a good deal for the Bengals or is it even a viable option for us? Would a transaction similar to this one help both teams? Is #85 too controversial or too old to figure into the Panther's plans at all?

It won't happen but I'd make that trade.

[AntDogg]

Originally Posted by pigskincrazy

Peppers seems intent upon leaving the Panthers, and could be the bona fide pass rushing specialist that the Bengals are desperate to add to our defense. Chad may be indispensable to our offense, at this time, with the departure of TJ? I don't know if the Bengals will land a 3rd or 4th round comp pick in this year's Draft to partially offset the team's having to give up a draft pick, along with #85, to get this deal done.

Is Peppers too old at age 29 to be a good pick up for the Bengals, who can play both DE and OLB? Can the Bengals find a viable substitute for #85 on our current roster to replace him with as a deep threat like Henry, perhaps, or are we too thin at the WR position?

Will Delhomme be able to get the ball to Chad, and would Johnson be a good complement to Steve Smith for the Carolina Panthers?

So would this be a good deal for the Bengals or is it even a viable option for us? Would a transaction similar to this one help both teams? Is #85 too controversial or too old to figure into the Panther's plans at all?

it would be nice, but won't even happen

[fredtoast]

Peppers is demanding a trade to a team that runs the 3-4 base defense.

Plus I don't like the trade anyway. We are WAY too thin a WR right now. We sure don't want to trade our only experienced guy.